Alphamar vs Fathom A penny pincher needs help here

[chuckd67]

Alright Guys, The Alphamar and Fathom reels have been in circulation for a while so I hope I can hear some reviews. Money is the main issue. The Alphamar 16 is on sell at Bottom Dwellers for $117 and the Fathom is $ 170.00. I have heard enough about the Fathom it is a great reel but with only 3 lbs of drag separating the two. Who has used the Alphamar and does $50.00 make a big difference between the two.

[Blackhorse]

I have them both. Both are excellent reels and I personally don't see 3 #'s of drag making that much difference. With Dave at Bottom Dwellers having the best price, and the customer service that he has, I see no reason to have any debate on what one to purchase, I would recommend the brand of choice for you. Now, I have the Alphamars and Cindy uses them with great success, I have also used them and they cast very well and work outstanding. I use the Fathom and see no difference in castablity and they are super good on big fish.

[Chuck]

You can't loose with either. I use and love both of them. My preference is the Fathom, but the Alphamar is great too.

[Chuck]

The Fathom is worth the extra cash to me.

[Chuck]

Hey Chuck, the Shimano Tekota is another fine choice available from Big Dave. We tried them out when we fished with Kip a few weeks back. REALLY smooth reels, cast like a dream. I still prefer the Penn over all the others, but the Shimano is a fine choice also.

[abudoc]

They are basically the same with the Penn having a few extras. Line capacity rings on the spool, adjustable handle length, drag washers that can be arranged to change max drag settings, a metal left side plate instead of graphite and a clicker on the spool tensioner.
They will both reel in any flathead so I vote to get the Alphamar while it is on sale.

[chuckd67]

Thanks guys, Alphamar 16 it is.